The 5 Biggest Misconceptions About the Mediterranean Diet

May 24, 2013
By

Kritamo

The Mediterranean diet has become the “it” diet. While it has been gaining popularity since the 1990’s when the Mediterranean diet Pyramid was presented by Harvard and the World Health Organization researchers along with other experts, today its popularity has reached new heights. Ever since the New York Times presented a recent Spanish study showing that the diet may be better for the heart than a low fat diet, the media has gone crazy. Numerous e-books on the diet literally appeared overnight, articles on the diet were everywhere, Mediterranean style recipes are popping up on all the food websites and blogs, and basically everybody not only has an opinion on the diet but they also feel that they can dispense advice on a diet that they may have never experienced themselves.

So here are the 5 biggest misconceptions going around:

1. There is no single Mediterranean diet.
Well, not exactly, there is one Mediterranean diet model. The Mediterranean diet was based on the diet of Cretan men in the 60’s and more generally Greece and Southern Italy of that period (read about it in this Harvard article). At that time the rates of chronic disease in those areas were among the lowest in the world, and life expectancy was among the highest. We often see articles stating that it is a combination of components of the diets of countries surrounding the Mediterranean. The diet of Crete and most of Greece and Southern Italy combined all those components, almost all other countries have locations where they do not follow a Mediterranean style diet, such as Northern Italy or Spain where meat is very prominent and some countries around the Mediterranean do not even use olive oil as the main sort of fat. So it is wrong to state that their is no single Mediterranean diet, there is one prototype. That doesn’t mean that you can’t combine Mediterranean components from all these countries, but it is important to know what diet did serve as the prototype for the well-known Mediterranean Diet.

2. Olive Oil should be drizzled on salads
Many articles advise you to drizzle a bit of olive oil on your salads or over cooked vegetables. There was a lot of discussion about the amount of olive oil used in that Spanish study: 4 tablespoons, and some thought that was way too much. Well, I have got news for you: You know that Cretan diet we were talking about earlier? Well in some cases their fat intake made 45% of the total calories of the diet. If you looked at Greeks cooking traditional vegetable recipes, you see them pouring the olive oil straight from the bottle. In Greek cuisine there is even a whole category of dishes named “lathera” which means “cooked in oil”. For a good lathero the rule was that you should actually see the olive oil among the vegetables after they are cooked. The meal as a whole had a moderate caloric value, because all you ate were vegetables cooked in olive oil, with some bread and cheese, so you did not see weight gain with that sort of meal. We have to remember that these people had to support themselves with what they produced and that was olive oil, vegetables and dairy. Vegetables and olive oil were used as a means to provide satiety, since they could not afford meat. So when reading all that advice, it makes me wonder if these experts really know what a Mediterranean diet is, if they did, they wouldn’t be telling people to add one teaspoon of olive oil to their food.

3. Nuts are a big part of the diet
Everywhere you read about the prominence of nuts in the Mediterranean diet. Well, they aren’t so prominent as it is suggested. Greeks would have walnuts at home when they were in season. Nuts, mainly almonds and walnuts were used mainly in sweets, and in some sauces such as skordalia (garlic sauce) but they were not a daily habit. Georgia Petraki, a Cretan Nutritionist who specializes in the traditional Cretan diet, tells me that the consumption of nuts in Crete at that time was seasonal and nuts generally were not available in large amounts. Each family may have had an almond tree, and when it was almond season the family ate some and the rest were saved as they were considered precious and served only to guests. So yes, nuts have a high nutritional value, but they are to be consumed 2-3 times a week, not every day.

4. Plenty of Pasta
Many people associate the Mediterranean diet with pasta and are worried it will make them fat.  While there is a good amount of starches in the diet, it’s not huge bowls of pasta but whole grains foods such as barley rusks, whole wheat bread as well as potatoes, polenta, rice and of course pasta. So pasta can be a part of the diet, depending on the area. But it is usually an accompaniment and not drowned in butter and cream based sauces. Enjoy your pasta, but make sure it’s made with an olive oil or tomato based sauce, accompanied by plenty of vegetables.

5. The Mediterraneans follow the Mediterranean diet
In the articles I’ve written in the past I make it clear that when I talk about a Greek-Mediterranean diet, I am referring to the traditional Greek diet. Unfortunately many Mediterraneans do not follow their famous traditional diet any more. No, we don’t sit around having long lunches with family and friends every day, nor do we eat meat once a month. More and more Greeks are eating fast food meals at their desk accompanied by a Coke. More and more Greeks are eating meat everyday rather then a lathero dish. And more and more Greeks (and Italians, and Spaniards) are becoming obese. You might think: “it’s all that olive oil they pour on their food”. I wish it were all that olive oil, I wish Greeks would use only olive oil. But the fact of the matter is that it’s exactly the opposite: Greeks slowly have stopped eating their traditional food, which happens to be one of the healthiest in the world. Processed foods have become prominent in the average diet of the modern Greek.

Photo by Olive Tomato
LinkedInFacebook

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

10 Responses to The 5 Biggest Misconceptions About the Mediterranean Diet

  1. Brenda
    May 24, 2013 at 5:57 pm

    Another Great article! Thanks.

    • Elena Paravantes RD
      May 24, 2013 at 6:51 pm

      Thanks Brenda!

  2. Alexandros
    May 25, 2013 at 10:07 am

    My dear Elena,your article is music to my ears. We have a good annual olive oil production from southern Greece (Kiparissia)and this is the only fat used in my family. The only butter that enters our fridge is the one my wife uses for cakes. (do you by any chance have any ideas of cakes made with olive oil ? :))
    Of course what is of paramount importance is the quality of the olive oil which, unfortunately, cannot be relied upon, at least with the commercially available stuff. Even the traditional producers selling it on ntenekedes, started cutting corners and compromising quality (O tempora o mores).
    If you really want to try some REAL virgin oil talk to me.
    Cheers … Alex

  3. George H
    May 27, 2013 at 12:06 am

    Comments about nuts and pasta make sense.

    But perhaps a little clarification olive oil. Maybe the Greeks pour olive oil into their dishes. Maybe they drink it (at the right circumstance). But it appears to me that it would be incomplete if we believe an individual, Greek or not, can eat much more olive oil in any form than her/his body needs.

    To be clear, an ounce of olive oil is an ounce of oil. 250 calories. If you eat 10 tablespoons of oil, that’s 5 ounces, or 1250 calories. That means you can eat 10 tablespoons of oil, which is a lot for many people, make that you daily intake, and still have your total daily calorie intake under control (as long as you don’t eat too much of other foods).

    In other words, no one can escape the reality that if you eat far more calories than your body will need, you gain weight, olive oil or not.

    So this “pouring olive oil” is subject this constraint. Do you not think so?

    There can also be missing context that is common in many reports. For example, maybe the healthy Greeks you refer to have very healthy live style. This does not need to mean rigorous exercise. But rather they are active people, walking a lot in the day, around town, to their friends, neighbors and to cafes and newsstands, attend to their gardens, instead of sitting in front of a TV or a computer like most modern people do all day. This way, they can afford to eat a bit more.

    In a comment you posted in Marion Nestle’s blog, you also mentioned Greeks fast a lot. That means they eat in moderation most of the time, in addition to an over all low calorie diet other than olive oil. So they can afford more olive oil. In this context, the rich nutrients in olive oil becomes very beneficial.

    Wonder how you think.

    • Elena Paravantes RD
      May 27, 2013 at 5:56 am

      Thanks George for your comment. As I mentioned in the article, these meals rich in olive oil consisted of mainly vegetables accompanied by a bit of cheese and bread, so the total calorie content is still moderate.Also to clarify I did not say or recommend that anyone consume 10 Tablespoons of olive oil. I have written about the olive oil issue several times, this link may help you understand the consumption of olive oil within the context of the Mediterranean diet: http://www.olivetomato.com/five-steps-to-eat-more-like-a-mediterranean-this-year-step-1-dont-be-afraid-of-the-olive-oil/

      • George H
        May 27, 2013 at 3:36 pm

        Thanks for the comment.

        If 40% of daily intake comes from fat, for a 2500 calorie individual, that can mean (a bit more than) 10 tablespoons.

        Nonetheless, I clearly didn’t mean you advocate 10 tablespoons. I just threw it out there as an example. But I am glad you clarified.

        Modern people, especially my fellow Americans, never understand and appreciate “moderation”. They want quick indulgence and instant gratification, both in consumption (meaning eating far more fat and sugar than they ever need) and health (gain health and lose weight for doing nothing after devouring foods). Just funny.

        So the Mediterranean/Greek diet is as much a life style as it is a diet. This I appreciate very much. And instead of “olive oil has antioxidants and is one of the best sources of the good monounsaturated fat”, I would say it THE best source. I use olive oil almost as my sole source of fat, except when I succumb to frying (canola) and baking (a bit of butter). But I limit that to no more than10% of my fat consumption.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.